In August 2004, I wrote about 2 Historic Trail issues from Man-a-Hattin Lodge #82. Subsequently I learned from David Axxx. The former Lodge advisor, that Man-A-Hattin Lodge has always sponsored the Old New York Historic Trail.
While earlier issues for the Trail did not contain the Lodge name or number, they were bought, paid and issued by the lodge. there were at least one solid and several twill varieties of the trail patches issued by the Lodge.
By that arguement, I would think that these items would be considered lodge issues. Of course your mileage may vary.
I have arbitrarily called this the R2 although I do not know when it was issued in relation to the R1.
Blue Book Style stats:
R2 YEL R LBL – YEL FDL; BLK The Old New York Historical Trail no indication of Lodge name or number
Weather forecast for tonight: dark. Continued dark overnight, with widely scattered light by morning.—- George Carlin (1937 – 2008)